Technical track
Writing a trading plan you will actually follow
Most trading plans are a description of a setup. That is the easy part. A plan earns its keep by settling the decisions you will be tempted to make while money is moving, in advance and in writing.
Why plans fail
Plans usually fail in one of two ways. Either they specify the entry and nothing else, so the difficult moments are left to judgement in real time. Or they are written long and aspirational, which means nobody reads them, including the person who wrote them.
There is a documented reason the difficult moments are difficult. Loss aversion means losses are felt more sharply than equivalent gains, and the more often you evaluate your results, the more that asymmetry shows up in your decisions. Benartzi and Thaler describe investors who are "distinctly more sensitive to losses than to gains" and who evaluate their portfolios frequently.15 The practical reading is not to avoid looking at your account. It is to review decisions on a schedule instead of checking profit and loss continuously while a position is open.
The five decisions a plan has to settle
Everything below is a decision you are allowed to make once, calmly, rather than many times, badly. Write each one as a rule that could be checked by somebody else.
1. What you trade, and when
- Which instruments, and why those.
- Which session, expressed as clock times.
- Which events you do not hold a position through.
- Which days you do not trade at all, if any.
2. What qualifies as a setup
State it mechanically enough that another trader could mark the same chart and reach the same answer. If the rule needs you to judge whether the market "looks strong", it is not a rule, and it will be applied generously on the days you need a trade.
3. How much you trade
Write the sizing formula rather than a fixed contract count, because the formula is what keeps risk per trade constant as the account changes. Then write the cap imposed by the firm, since micros count at ten to one against minis on some accounts.6 The arithmetic belongs in Position sizing and risk per trade.
4. What ends the trade
- Initial stop, expressed in points from entry.
- Target, and whether it is fixed or trailed.
- What happens at break even, and whether you take partial size off.
- A time stop, for trades that simply go nowhere.
- The rule for a gap or a fast move that jumps your stop.
5. What ends the day
- Your own daily loss stop, set inside the firm's daily limit.
- A maximum number of trades or losses, whichever comes first.
- The point at which you stop for the day after a win, so a good morning does not become a donation.
- What you do after the stop fires: leave the screen, or review the log without trading.
A one page template
Long enough to cover the decisions, short enough to read on a bad morning.
| Section | What goes in it |
|---|---|
| Account facts | Account size, maximum drawdown and its type, daily loss limit, max contracts, consistency rule.68 |
| My limits | My daily stop, my total stop, my risk per trade percentage. |
| Instruments and hours | What I trade, when, and which events I stand aside for. |
| Setup definition | The mechanical conditions, in the order I check them. |
| Sizing | The formula, and the cap. |
| Trade management | Stop, target, break even rule, time stop. |
| Day management | Daily stop, trade cap, what happens after two losses. |
| Review | When I review, and what I am allowed to change at that point. |
Pre-commit the exceptions, or have none
Every plan meets a day that it did not anticipate. There are two honest ways to handle that, and one dishonest one.
- Honest option one: no exceptions. The plan says what happens, and when reality does not fit, the plan says stand aside. This is the simplest plan to follow and the one most likely to survive.
- Honest option two: a written exception clause, decided in advance, with a limit. For example, if a scheduled economic release lands inside the trade window, the maximum size is halved rather than the trade skipped.
- The dishonest option: deciding in the moment that this case is different. This is how a plan becomes a story about a plan.
The plan is a hypothesis, not a monument
Change the plan at review time, never during a session. If a rule was broken, the first question is whether the rule was wrong or was ignored, and those two problems have different fixes. A rule that gets ignored three sessions in a row is usually a rule that does not fit the way you actually trade, which is worth knowing and worth rewriting at the desk rather than mid trade.
The review process itself is covered in Journaling and review that changes behaviour.
Could you hand this to somebody else, with no further explanation, and could they take the trades you would have taken? If not, the plan still has decisions in it that are being made live.
Sources
The number next to each claim above is a stable source id. The same number means the same source on every page of this site.
- 6Trading Combine ParametersTopstep
- 8Intraday Trailing Drawdown Performance Accounts (PA)Apex Trader Funding
- 15Myopic Loss Aversion and the Equity Premium PuzzleBenartzi and Thaler, The Quarterly Journal of Economics 110(1), NBER Working Paper 4369